The European Parliament has decided to lift the parliamentary immunity of András Tivadar Kulja, a Hungarian MEP, in the context of criminal proceedings for defamation brought against him by a private complainant in Hungary. This decision allows the Hungarian authorities to pursue the case. The vote was taken by show of hands, without an individual count of votes. This is not a law but an internal decision of the Parliament.
András Tivadar Kulja, elected to the European Parliament in June 2024, is the subject of a private defamation complaint following a Facebook post on 31 July 2025. The Pest Central District Court requested the lifting of his immunity on 11 December 2025. The Parliament heard the person concerned on 28 September 2026 before taking its decision.
Immunity lifted for KuljaThe European Parliament lifts the parliamentary immunity of András Tivadar Kulja, thereby allowing the criminal proceedings for defamation to run their course in Hungary.
Immediate transmission of the decisionThe President of the European Parliament is instructed to transmit the decision without delay to the competent Hungarian judicial authority and to András Tivadar Kulja.
Scope limited to the criminal proceedingsThis lifting of immunity concerns only the proceedings brought by a private complainant for alleged acts of defamation committed in 2025. It does not prejudge in any way the guilt or innocence of Mr Kulja.
The decision was adopted by show of hands. No individual count of votes is available.
For Hungarian citizens, this decision means that the courts can now examine a defamation complaint against a European MEP without parliamentary immunity standing in the way. It illustrates the fact that immunity protects the exercise of parliamentary duties and not the person themselves. The proceedings will continue before the Hungarian courts.
The European Parliament has lifted the immunity of András Tivadar Kulja, a Hungarian MEP, in connection with a private defamation complaint. A decision that reminds us that immunity protects the parliamentary function, not the person.
Parliamentary immunity is not a personal shield. It exists to guarantee that MEPs can express their opinions and vote without fear of intimidating prosecution. In this case, the Parliament judged that the disputed publication, a Facebook message of 31 July 2025 alleging that public funds linked to purchases of medical equipment had benefited a family business, did not fall within the exercise of parliamentary duties within the meaning of Article 8 of Protocol No 7. The request to lift immunity came from the Central District Court of Pest, seised by a private complainant, and not from a political authority. The Parliament therefore followed the usual procedure: it heard the person concerned on 28 September 2026, then decided, by show of hands, to lift immunity.
This decision has a concrete consequence: the Hungarian courts will be able to examine the complaint on the merits. For citizens, this means that no MEP can escape ordinary criminal proceedings by invoking an immunity that does not cover defamatory statements. This is good news for the rule of law: immunity must remain a strictly circumscribed exception, not a discretionary privilege.
The Parliament could have referred the request to the Committee on Legal Affairs for closer examination, but it chose to decide quickly. In doing so, it sends a clear signal: allegations of corruption or favouritism must be able to be examined by the courts, and MEPs must be accountable like any citizen. The defamation proceedings, for their part, will have to demonstrate whether the statements made were well founded or not. Nothing in the Parliament's decision prejudges the outcome of the trial.
A vote by show of hands does not make it possible to know the distribution of votes by political group. This can be regretted: on a question touching on immunity and freedom of expression, transparency would have been preferable. Voters have the right to know who supported the lifting of immunity and who opposed it. A roll-call vote would have made that scrutiny possible. This is not a detail: parliamentary immunity is a powerful mechanism, and its use must be traceable.
That said, the decision itself is consistent with the logic of subsidiarity: it is for the Hungarian courts, not a European body, to settle the dispute. The Parliament confined itself to removing the procedural obstacle, without ruling on the merits. That is the right approach. An alternative would have been to refer the case back to the Committee on Legal Affairs for a longer examination, but that would have delayed a procedure that has already been running for more than a year. Speed, here, serves justice.
Immunity is not a personal privilege: it protects the function, not the person.
The European Parliament has lifted the immunity of András Tivadar Kulja, a Hungarian MEP, in connection with a private defamation complaint. A decision that reminds us that immunity protects the parliamentary function, not the person.
Parliamentary immunity is not a personal shield. It exists to guarantee that MEPs can express their opinions and vote without fear of intimidating prosecution. In this case, the Parliament judged that the disputed publication, a Facebook message of 31 July 2025 alleging that public funds linked to purchases of medical equipment had benefited a family business, did not fall within the exercise of parliamentary duties within the meaning of Article 8 of Protocol No 7. The request to lift immunity came from the Central District Court of Pest, seised by a private complainant, and not from a political authority. The Parliament therefore followed the usual procedure: it heard the person concerned on 28 September 2026, then decided, by show of hands, to lift immunity.
This decision has a concrete consequence: the Hungarian courts will be able to examine the complaint on the merits. For citizens, this means that no MEP can escape ordinary criminal proceedings by invoking an immunity that does not cover defamatory statements. This is good news for the rule of law: immunity must remain a strictly circumscribed exception, not a discretionary privilege.
The Parliament could have referred the request to the Committee on Legal Affairs for closer examination, but it chose to decide quickly. In doing so, it sends a clear signal: allegations of corruption or favouritism must be able to be examined by the courts, and MEPs must be accountable like any citizen. The defamation proceedings, for their part, will have to demonstrate whether the statements made were well founded or not. Nothing in the Parliament's decision prejudges the outcome of the trial.
A vote by show of hands does not make it possible to know the distribution of votes by political group. This can be regretted: on a question touching on immunity and freedom of expression, transparency would have been preferable. Voters have the right to know who supported the lifting of immunity and who opposed it. A roll-call vote would have made that scrutiny possible. This is not a detail: parliamentary immunity is a powerful mechanism, and its use must be traceable.
That said, the decision itself is consistent with the logic of subsidiarity: it is for the Hungarian courts, not a European body, to settle the dispute. The Parliament confined itself to removing the procedural obstacle, without ruling on the merits. That is the right approach. An alternative would have been to refer the case back to the Committee on Legal Affairs for a longer examination, but that would have delayed a procedure that has already been running for more than a year. Speed, here, serves justice.
Immunity is not a personal privilege: it protects the function, not the person.