The European Parliament has authorised Austria to amend its bilateral road transport agreement with Switzerland of 22 October 1958 to allow cabotage, that is, the transport of passengers between two points located on the same side of the border, in the Austrian-Swiss border regions. This authorisation applies to international coach and bus services between the two countries and remains subject to two conditions: no discrimination between carriers established in the Union and no distortion of competition. The text is Parliament's final position, already accepted by the Union governments; it will become law after their formal approval.
The agreement between the Union and Switzerland on the transport of goods and passengers does not authorise cabotage between two points in the same country. However, cabotage rights already provided for in bilateral agreements prior to 21 June 1999 may be maintained, provided that the rules on non-discrimination and competition are respected. The 1958 Austrian-Swiss agreement did not provide for this right. As these international commitments fall within the exclusive competence of the Union, Austria may only amend its agreement with the Union's consent. The Commission had proposed this authorisation; Parliament approved it.
Authorisation to amend the 1958 agreementAustria is authorised to amend the bilateral road transport agreement that has bound it to Switzerland since 22 October 1958, in order to introduce cabotage for international passenger transport services by coach and bus between the two countries.
Five border districts concernedThe authorised cabotage covers only the administrative districts of Bludenz, Bregenz, Dornbirn and Feldkirch in the Vorarlberg region, as well as the district of Landeck in the Tyrol region.
Two cumulative conditionsThe authorisation is valid only if there is no discrimination between carriers established in the Union and no distortion of competition.
Obligation to inform the CommissionAustria must inform the European Commission of the amendment to the agreement and communicate to it the text of the amended agreement. The Commission must then inform the European Parliament and the Council thereof.
Addressee of the decisionThe Republic of Austria is the sole addressee of this decision.
Parliament adopted the text by 654 votes in favour, 4 against and 1 abstention, in an electronic roll-call vote.
In practice, transport companies established in Austria will be able, in the five border districts mentioned, to pick up passengers for domestic journeys in Switzerland and vice versa, during international coach or bus services. Travellers in these border areas could thus have more direct connections between the two countries. Carriers established in the Union must not be discriminated against in relation to Swiss carriers, and competition must not be distorted. This measure does not create a general right to cabotage throughout the Union: it is limited to the named Austrian districts and to the relationship with Switzerland.
The European Parliament has authorized Austria to amend its bilateral road transport agreement with Switzerland of 22 October 1958 to allow cabotage in five border districts. The text was adopted by 654 votes in favor, 4 against and 1 abstention. This decision is the Parliament's final position, already accepted by the governments of the Union; it will become law after their formal approval. This is not a general liberalization of cabotage, but a targeted, conditional and revocable opening.
Cabotage, that is, the transport of passengers between two points located on the same side of the border, was until now prohibited by the Austro-Swiss agreement of 1958. The European Union authorizes Austria to permit it, but only in five border districts and only during international coach and bus services between the two countries. This geographical and material limitation is a good thing: it avoids opening a general right to cabotage throughout the Union, which would have exposed European carriers to unregulated competition.
The two conditions, non-discrimination between carriers established in the Union and absence of distortion of competition, are the counterpart of this opening. They protect European carriers against a competitive advantage that would be granted to Swiss operators. But they remain vague notions, whose interpretation and enforcement will fall to the Commission and, ultimately, to the Court of Justice. For businesses, this means limited legal certainty: they will have to document their compliance, which represents a certain administrative cost.
The authorization is strictly framed: it applies only to the named districts and to the relationship with Switzerland. No review or revision clause is provided. If the market evolves, a new political decision will be needed. This status quo protects established carriers, but it freezes the possibilities for extension. Travelers in border areas could benefit from additional direct connections, but only in these five districts. Elsewhere, nothing changes.
The information procedure requires Austria to notify the Commission and transmit to it the text of the amended agreement. The Commission then informs the Parliament and the Council. This mechanism is light and proportionate. It does not create a new heavy bureaucracy, but it maintains political control over an exclusive external competence of the Union. One may regret that there is no annual report on the concrete effects of this opening, but it is not indispensable.
A targeted, conditional and revocable authorization: this is how Europe should open its markets, not through uniform regulations.
The European Parliament has authorized Austria to amend its bilateral road transport agreement with Switzerland of 22 October 1958 to allow cabotage in five border districts. The text was adopted by 654 votes in favor, 4 against and 1 abstention. This decision is the Parliament's final position, already accepted by the governments of the Union; it will become law after their formal approval. This is not a general liberalization of cabotage, but a targeted, conditional and revocable opening.
Cabotage, that is, the transport of passengers between two points located on the same side of the border, was until now prohibited by the Austro-Swiss agreement of 1958. The European Union authorizes Austria to permit it, but only in five border districts and only during international coach and bus services between the two countries. This geographical and material limitation is a good thing: it avoids opening a general right to cabotage throughout the Union, which would have exposed European carriers to unregulated competition.
The two conditions, non-discrimination between carriers established in the Union and absence of distortion of competition, are the counterpart of this opening. They protect European carriers against a competitive advantage that would be granted to Swiss operators. But they remain vague notions, whose interpretation and enforcement will fall to the Commission and, ultimately, to the Court of Justice. For businesses, this means limited legal certainty: they will have to document their compliance, which represents a certain administrative cost.
The authorization is strictly framed: it applies only to the named districts and to the relationship with Switzerland. No review or revision clause is provided. If the market evolves, a new political decision will be needed. This status quo protects established carriers, but it freezes the possibilities for extension. Travelers in border areas could benefit from additional direct connections, but only in these five districts. Elsewhere, nothing changes.
The information procedure requires Austria to notify the Commission and transmit to it the text of the amended agreement. The Commission then informs the Parliament and the Council. This mechanism is light and proportionate. It does not create a new heavy bureaucracy, but it maintains political control over an exclusive external competence of the Union. One may regret that there is no annual report on the concrete effects of this opening, but it is not indispensable.
A targeted, conditional and revocable authorization: this is how Europe should open its markets, not through uniform regulations.